FileMaker Pro Relational Databases

Published by

  • cours - matière potentielle : setting
  • button at the bottom of the window
  • fun part
  • text days
  • file menu
  • dialog box
  • description
  • days
  • time
Published : Tuesday, March 27, 2012
Reading/s : 24
Origin :
Number of pages: 12
See more See less


Lesson #4:

Case Study—



(Video Clips)

Lesson Plan................................................................ ................... 137

Teacher Guide.............. 138

Student Worksheet........................................................................ 145

Video Clips .................. DVD

Living Together
Malaysian Palm Oil Council
Coming Soon: Orangutan Extinction



Video Clip
Case Study: Rainforest Biodiversity
Lesson Objectives:
• Students will review issues related to rainforest biodiversity.
• Students will understand impacts on biodiversity from monoculture plantations that
produce single crops for the global market.
• Students will recognize the power of words, images and sound to bias impressions.
• Students will analyze credibility, bias and truth in educational, corporate and citizen action
Biodiversity, tropical rainforest, palm oil plantation, monoculture, Indonesia, Borneo,
Sumatra, Malaysian Palm Oil Council, Palm Oil Action, sustainable production


Orangutan, Sierra Living Together, Malaysian Palm Oil Coming Soon: Orangutan
Club Series, 1988 Planet Earth, 2007 Council, CNN, Extinction, Hatchling
(3:10) (2:47) 2007 (1:00) Productions, 2007 (1:19)

Materials Needed:
• Teacher’s guide: Rainforest Biodiversity
• Four video clips on DVD
• One-page Lesson #4 Case Study Student Worksheet
50 minutes

Lesson Procedures:
1. Present Lesson Introduction to the class
2. Distribute Student Worksheet for logging the clips
3. Play the video clips while students log their answers
4. Lead students through a decoding of the video clips using Media Sample Questions & Answers
Teacher’s Guide
5. Discuss funding sources and credibility in films using Further Questions



Video Clips
Case Study: Rainforest Biodiversity

1. Organize and make copies for the class activities.
2. Introduce the lesson:
Background Information

In his book, The Future of Life (Slide 19) renowned biologist E. O. Wilson writes, “The headquar-
ters of global biodiversity are the tropical rainforests. Although they cover only about 6% of the land surface, their terrestrial and aquatic habitats contain more than half the known species of organisms. They are also the leading abattoir (slaughterhouse) of extinction, shattered into frag- ments that are then being severely adulterated or erased one by one. Of all ecosystems, they are
rivaled in rate of decline only by the temperate rainforests and tropical dry forests” (Wilson 59).

Rainforest destruction has been an issue of concern within the United Nations since the 1980s.
The United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Forests (IPF) has established a set of 270 pro-
pos als for action for the promotion of the management, conservation and sustainable develop-
m ent of all types of forests (UNFF). In 2007, the World Index of Social and Environmental Re-
sponsibility database counted the same number of organizations, 270, devoted to the preserva-
tion of tropical rainforests (Hawken 294).

The videos you will see focus on one particular case study within the vast array of concerns re-
lated to rainforest destruction, that of Indonesian palm oil plantations and their impact on biodi-
versity. When E. O. Wilson wrote The Future of Life in 2002, he warned, “eighty percent of the
(Indonesian rain) forest cover has been committed to logging and replacement by oil palm and other plantations, and rapid clearing is under way” (Wilson 66). This figure has certainly risen since then.

Lesson Introduction
The videos you are about to view represent two distinct styles of filmmaking. The first two are ex-
cerpts from nature documentaries. The other two are ads made by an industry group and an activist
group. As you view these clips you will be asked to contrast points of view regarding rainforest bio-
diversity and film making techniques that convey those viewpoints. Please remember the first two
brief excerpts are not meant to show the full story as told in the much longer works from which they
are taken.

3. Distribute student worksheets. Have students work individually or in pairs to log each film.
4. Read aloud the brief introductory excerpt before playing each film clip.
5. Play the film clip.
6. Have students write their answers on their worksheet after the showing of the clip.
7. Lead a discussion of the clips using the suggested teacher answers below as a guide.

Orangutan, Sierra Club Series, 1988

Film 1 Introduction

This excerpt is from the 1988 film Orangutan made by the Survival Anglia production company
and marketed by Eastman Kodak as part of the Sierra Club Series on endangered wildlife. The
video jacket describes the film: “This film, narrated by Peter Ustinov, provides a compelling ac-
count of the imperiled condition of the rare and endearing orangutan, the animal whose name
means “man of the forest.”

This was filmed on the island of Sumatra, next to Borneo in Indonesia.

Media Sample Questions & Answers

1.) What is the impact of Possible Answer: The film does not mention palm oil plantations but sug-
palm oil plantations on rain- gests that any cutting of the rainforest is dangerous for people and wildlife.
forest diversity? Give evi- Evidence: The opening images and narration regarding the effect of the
dence to justify your an- lumber operations on the single orangutan suggest that rainforest cutting
swer. will threaten orangutans. The later images of the hillside that has been clear-
cut and the narrator’s words – “natural disaster...that could drastically affect
their own lives” suggest danger to people as well.

2.) What techniques do the Possible Answer: They persuade the viewer to feel sympathy for the ape by
filmmakers use to persuade showing the “real life drama” of the timber crew cutting the trees next to the
or inform? Consider choices large orangutan. The falling branch and the image of the orangutan with its
in scripting, visuals, audio hands over its head are meant to evoke impending doom and pity. The nar-

background and voice-over ration adds to the drama: “This magnificent animal is fighting for its very
in your answer. existence as more and more of his forest home is hacked away.” The oboe
and percussion create an unsettling background score to reinforce these im-
pressions. The aerial shots of the extensive hillside cut juxtaposed with the
following images of jungle and river show the dramatic difference between
3.) What is left out of this a living forest and one that has been cut.
message that might be useful
to know? Possible Answer: There is no mention of the palm oil industry’s effect on the
orangutan’s range, likely because this film was made before palm oil planta-
tions became a major industry in Indonesia. There is no reference here to the
4.) This note appears at the “wonderful people” who are helping the ape. (Such information makes up
end of the video: “All the the main part of the full video) There is no mention of how the local people
scenes in this pictorial essay and timber workers feel about the cutting of the forest.
whether actual or crated
represent authenticated Possible Answer: The note suggests that some of what is shown may in fact
facts.” How can you judge be staged. This might lead one to wonder whether the rest of the informa-
the credibility of the tion is accurate. To judge the credibility one would have to research other
information offered? sources on orangutans and rainforest depletion in Sumatra during the


Living Together, Planet Earth, 2007

Film 2 Introduction

This excerpt is from an episode entitled “Living Together” from the BBC TV series, Planet
Earth. The DVD set of the series was distributed by Warner Home Video which promoted the
product as follows: “With an unprecedented production budget, using high definition photog-

raphy and revolutionary ultra-high speed cameras, five years in the making, over 2000 days in

the field, using 40 cameramen across 200 locations, Planet Earth is the ultimate portrait of our


Media Sample Questions & Answers

Possible Answer: A majority of those interviewed (three out of four) suggest 1.) What is the impact of
that palm oil plantations dramatically reduce rainforest diversity. One inter-palm oil plantations on
viewee suggests that rainforest depletion has been overstated. rainforest diversity? Give
Evidence: M.A. Sanjayan, lead scientist of the Nature Conservancy: “a evidence to justify your an-
monoculture reducing the rainforest to small chunks.” Huw Cordey, Planet swer.
Earth producer.” an oil palm plantation is the antithesis of a rainfor-
est…reducing your diversity enormously.” James Lovelock, independent sci-
entist: “the tropical rainforest (has) great diversity…that cannot be replaced by a single plantation of trees.” Peyton Knight, National Center for Public Policy research: “I view with a great deal of skepticism reports in how fast 2.) What techniques do the
the rainforest is decreasing.” film makers use to persuade
or inform? Consider
Possible Answer: They choose to include three out of four speakers with a choices in scripting, visuals,
similar perspective. They intersperse the interview frames with images of audio background and
tree cutting, sounds of a chainsaw and a long pan of large palm oil planta-voice-over in your answer.
tions with a background of ominous low tone orchestral sounds to visually
underscore the tragedy of rainforest depletion. They include an interview in
which a frowning filmmaker says that seeing the oil palm plantations “was
depressing…almost brought tears to your eyes.” They use an aerial view of
clouds amongst rainforest trees backed with rainforest animal sounds to 3.) What is left out of this
highlight the role of the rainforest in the water cycle. message that might be use-
ful to know?
Possible Answer: What do the people who live or work on the palm oil
plantations think? What does palm oil production have to do with the likely 4.) What actions might you
viewer of this program in Britain or the U.S.? What are people doing to stop take in response to this
rainforest depletion? What are the benefits of palm oil? message?

Possible Answer: Answers will vary depending on individual choice and
point of view.

Malaysian Palm Oil Council, CNN, 2007
Film 3 Introduction
This ad was made by the Malaysian Palm Oil Council for broadcast in the U.S. on CNN. The
Advertising Standards Authority filed a complaint about this ad, alleging that “the ad mislead-
ingly implied that palm oil plantations were as bio-diverse and sustainable as the native rainfor-
ests they replaced.” The Malaysian Palm Oil Council responded in a press release that it was
“extremely disappointed with the Advertising Standards Authority’s verdict. We do not feel that
the advertisements mislead in any way, and we stand by our claim that Malaysian palm oil is
produced sustainably. Malaysia has numerous laws in place going back to the 1920s to ensure
that we protect and nurture our natural and human resources, which we are well aware are fi-
nite and precious” (MPOC).

Media Sample Questions & Answers
natural and human resources, which we are well aware are finite and precious.” (MPOC)

Possible Answer: Palm oil plantations enhance biodiversity. 1.) What is the impact of palm oil
Evidence: Palm oil plants are shown interspersed with images plantations on rainforest diversity?
of plants and animals with a voice-over: “This gift for nature, Give evidence to justify your an-
this gift for life, Malaysian palm oil… It gives life, vitamins, swer.

Possible Answer: The images of the young man running 2.) What techniques do the filmmak-
through the plantation and stopping to appreciate nature put ers use to persuade or inform? Con-
the viewer in the role of appreciating what is presented as a sider choices in scripting, visuals,
palm oil plantation. The soft and calming music and the im-audio background and voice-over in
ages of hummingbird, water drops and forest-like surroundings your answer.
add to the idea that a palm oil plantation is a good place to
embrace nature.

Possible Answer: What existed in this pace before the planta-
tion? Were people or animals displaced to create this planta-3.) What is left out of this message
tion? How does cutting down the original forest impact the that might be useful to know?
ecosystem? Who benefits from palm oil monoculture and who
is harmed? What does “sustainably produced since 1917”
mean? How can one know if palm oil is in a particular product
and if it is sustainably produced?

Possible Answer: This was made to sell palm oil to an interna-4.) Why was this made and who paid
tional audience who has likely been exposed to information for it? Explain your conclusions.
such as that presented in the previous two films. The fact that
the Malaysian Palm Oil Council sponsored this ad suggests
that its message will further the council’s efforts to make
profits for that industry.


Coming Soon: Orangutan Extinction

Hatchling Productions, 2007
Film 4 Introduction
This clip, “Coming Soon: Orangutan Extinction,” was made by the Australian company,
Hatchling productions, as a trailer for a film entitled, Palm Oil: The Movie. Palm Oil Action,
the Australian group referenced at the end of the clip, states as its objectives: “Encourage im-
porters, food manufacturers and other companies who are currently using palm oil to imple-
ment a range of positive initiatives; Urge the Australian and NZ Governments to implement
policies to ensure the labeling of products containing palm oil and Encourage individuals, as
consumers, to take action on this issue by raising their concerns with retailers and manufac-
turers who use palm oil.”
Media Sample Questions & Answers
1.) What is the impact of palm Possible Answer: Palm oil plantations destroy biodiversity.
oil plantations on rainforest Evidence: A devastated landscape is shown along with the voice over: “Palm
diversity? Give evidence to jus- oil companies incinerate the Indonesian forest just so you can buy fried
tify your answer. chicken… Save the orangutans from palm oil.”

2.) What techniques do the Possible Answer: The images of the empty landscape, the fire, the
filmmakers use to persuade or orangutan crossing the charred earth and being captured and im-
inform? Consider choices in prisoned, hurricane damage, factory smokestacks, effluent pipes all
scripting, visuals, audio back- suggest that palm oil plantations are bad. The emphatic music and
ground and voice-over in your keening vocals raise anxiety. The fake film titles “Palm Oil: Rated N
answer. for Nasty” and the urgent male voice over add to this effect. The im-
ages of grocery shelves and familiar products inform the viewer that
palm oil may be in products he or she consumes.

3.) What is left out of this mes- Possible Answer: What is sustainable production and how can one
sage that might be useful to find out if a product is produced sustainably? How much of this foot-
know? age, i.e. the smokestack, effluent pipe, burning forest, clear-cut land-
scape is from Indonesian palm oil plantations and how much from
elsewhere? How do the local workers and villagers feel about the
effort to curtail the production of palm oil? What is the palm oil in-
dustry’s response to these charges?

4.) Why was this made and Possible Answer: This was made to incite outrage and activism
who paid for it? Explain your among viewers to stop palm oil plantation’s contribution to rainfor-
conclusions. est depletion. The concluding message to “Save the orangutans from
palm oil” and “coming soon to a supermarket near you. Rated bad
for you and everything else” urges the viewer to take this personally
and to take action. The credits suggest that it was made by
Hatchling Productions and refer viewers to the Web site palmoilac- It’s unclear who might have paid for the production
of this video.

» After you have decoded the films, lead a discussion about the power of
words, images, and sound to bias impressions and about credibility, bias and
truth in various forms of documentary film and advertising.


» How do funding sources (corporate – BBC Warner and Malaysian Palm Oil Council

vs. citizen action group – Sierra Club and Palm Oil Action) impact the filmmakers’

perspectives on the topic?
» Who might benefit from each film and who might be harmed?
» What important information is left out of these excerpts?
» What kinds of actions might one take in response to each film?
» How credible are these sources?
» How could you find additional information about rainforest destruction and palm oil
plantations today?
» How many items in your kitchen contain palm oil?
» What group do you know that is working to protect endangered species?


See lesson 1 PowerPoint slides #20 & 21 (orangutan and palm oil)
See lesson 1 power point slides #20 & 21 (orangutan and palm oil)



Be the first to leave a comment!!

12/1000 maximum characters.