RHETORIC and EXPERIENCE ARCHITECTURE
EDITED BY LIZA POTTS and MICHAEL J. SALVO
RHETORIC AND EXPERIENCE ARCHITECTURE
RHETORIC AND EXPERIENCE ARCHITECTURE
Edited by Liza Potts and Michael J. Salvo
Parlor Press Anderson, South Carolina www.parlorpress.com
Palo Pess LLC, Andeson, Souh Caolina, USA © 01 by Palo Pess All ighs eseved. Pined in he Unied Saes of Ameica on acid-Ree pape.
S A N: 5 4 - 8 8 9
Libay of Congess Caaloging-in-Publicaion Daa
Names: Pos, Liza, edio. | Salvo, Michael J., edio. Tile: heoic and expeience achiecue / edied by Liza Pos and Michael J. Salvo. Descipion: Andeson, Souh Caolina : Palo Pess, [0] | Includes bibliogaphical efeences and index. | Idenifies: LCCN 003854 (pin) | LCCN 00458 (ebook) | ISBN 986035968 (pdf) | ISBN 9860359635 (epub) | ISBN 986035986 ( ibook) | ISBN 9860359833 (mobi) | ISBN 9860359604 (pbk. : acid-Ree pape) | ISBN 98603596 (hadcove : acid-Ree pape) Subjecs: LCSH: Communicaion and echnology. | heoic--Technological innovaions. | Conen analysis (Communicaion) | Infomaion esouces managemen. | eseach--Mehodology. | Social change in lieaue. Classificaion: LCC P96.T4 (ebook) | LCC P96.T4 53 0 (pin) | DDC 808.0085--dc3 LC ecod available a hps://lccn.loc.gov/003854
98-1-6035-960-4 (papeback) 98-1-6035-961-1 (hadcove) 98-1-6035-96-8 (pdf) 98-1-6035-963-5 (epub) 98--6035-98-6 (ibook) 98--6035-983-3 (mobi)
3 4 5 Cove image: 016. Phoo by Michael Lechne on Unsplash. Used by pemission. Book Design: David Blakesley Copyediing by Jaed Jameson
Palo Pess, LLC is an independen publishe of scholaly and ade iles in pin and mulimedia fomas. This book is available in pape, cloh and eBook fo-mas Rom Palo Pess on he Wold Wide Web a hp://www.palopess.com o hough online and bick-and-moa booksoes. Fo submission infomaion o o find ou abou Palo Pess publicaions, wie o Palo Pess, 3015 Backen-bey Dive, Andeson, Souh Caolina, 961, o email edio@palopess.com.
Contents
Acknowledgments
Introduction 1
Liza Potts and Michael J. Salvo
2 Beckon, Encounter, Experience: The Danger of Control and the Promise of Encounters in the Study of User Experience
Patricia Sullivan
3 Experience Architecture: Drawing Principles from Life Roger Grice
4 Analyzing Activity for Experience Design Cheryl Geisler
5 Feminist Rhetorics and Interaction Design: Facilitating Socially Responsible Design Jennifer SanoFranchini
vii
3
17
41
57
84
6 Personas as Rhetorically Rich and Complex Mechanisms for Design111 Erin Friess
7 “Constructivist” Research Methods for Experience Architecture and Design
Heather Christiansen and Tharon Howard
8 Experience Architecture in Public Planning: A Material, Activist Practice Kristen Moore
v
122
143
9 Methodologies: Design Studies and Techne
Ehren Pflugfelder
10 Ethnography as Research Aggregator Andrew Mara and Miriam Mara
11 Audience Awareness: Resituating Experience Architecture as Execution Cait Ryan
12 Kairos and Managing Experience Architecture Projects Ben Lauren
13 Toward a Rhetoric of the Place: Creating Locative Experiences Anders Fagerjord
14 Dialogic, DataDriven Design: UX and League of Legends Cody Reimer
15 Making as Learning: Mozilla and Curriculum Design Rudy McDaniel and Cassie McDaniel
16 Memorial Interactivity: Scaffolding Nostalgic User Experiences William C. Kurlinkus
17 Designing Digital Activism: Rhetorical Tool as Agent of Social Change Douglas M. Walls, Delia M. Garcia, and Amy VanSchaik
18 Badges as Architectures of Experience: From Signaling to Communication Stephanie Vie, Rudy McDaniel, and Joseph R. Fanfarelli
166
184
197
209
225
241
258
274
291
304
19 Relocations: (Re)visioning Rhetoric in a Modern Amusement Park323 Jill Morris
Contributors Index
341 347
Acknowledgments
We wan o hank all he auhos who conibued o his volume. Ove a long and umuluous pah o publicaion, ou conibuos wee paien, pofessional, and poducive. Ou goal Rom he ouse was o ceae a fo-um fo academics and paciiones o shae hei expeience and, along he way, convince as many as we could ha expeience achiecue was a em ha accuaely descibed hei wok. Chales Sides was convinced ea-ly on, and offeed valuable feedback and advice a an impoan momen. Ashia Nichanamela, Ein Bock-Calson and Michelle McMullen offeed us gea insigh and helped us consuc anohe ineface fo eades o en-coune he book. We would also like o hank Laua Gonzalez whose wok on inenaional use expeience is helping us plan ou nex pojec. Mi-chael is gaeful o Liza fo pushing he pojec along when he jus could no even, and Liza is hankful fo Michael’s pesisence. We pesened ealy vesions of his wok a he Council fo Pogams in Technical and Scien-ific Communicaion (CPTSC), Confeence on College Composiion and Communicaion (CCCC), and he Associaion fo Teaches of Technical Wiing (ATTW) and ae hankful fo ou colleagues’ paien guidance and diecion duing ealy sages of he wok, and ae especially appeciaive fo he Associaion of Compuing Machiney’s Special Inees Goup on he Design of Communicaion (ACM-SIGDOC) fo helping us efine ou ap-poach and fo poviding excellen feedback in Silve Sping, Mayland and Limeick, Ieland. David Blakesley has a vision fo he fuue of academic publishing; Jaed Jameson has been shap-eyed. Any value hee is aibu-able o hese collaboaos and any misseps ae of ou own making. Ou spouses have been paien as we discussed wha we affecionae-ly efe o as “The XA,” disuping family ime. And o ou childen, Liza’s Zöe, Kaie, and Jayne and Michael’s Aila. Joy.
vii
RHETORIC AND EXPERIENCE ARCHITECTURE